Short answer
Modified thin-set has polymers added for stronger bond and some flexibility. It is the default for most porcelain tile on cement board, concrete and walls. Unmodified thin-set cures with water alone, and some membrane makers have specified it for tile set over their waterproof membranes. For tiles larger than about 15 inches, use a large-and-heavy-tile (LHT) mortar. Above all, use the mortar your membrane or board maker lists, or the warranty may not apply.
What thin-set is
Thin-set is a cement-based mortar that bonds tile to the surface beneath it. It is spread with a notched trowel and the tile is pressed into the ridges. Get the mortar or the coverage wrong, and tiles sound hollow, crack or come loose. That is one of the most common failures we're called to fix.
Modified vs unmodified
Both types start from the same base. What's added changes how each one cures and where it's allowed. Modified thin-set adds a latex polymer (or other polymers) that improves bond strength, flexibility and water resistance. Unmodified thin-set cures by reacting with water (hydration), so it doesn't depend on drying out. The polymers in a modified mortar have to dry before it can fully cure, and that one difference drives most of the choices below. Here are modified and unmodified thinset side by side:
| Unmodified (dry-set) | Modified | |
|---|---|---|
| What's in it | Portland cement, sand and water-retention agents | The same base with additional polymers (latex or acrylic) |
| How it's mixed | Mixed with water | One-part: mixed with water. Two-part: mixed with a liquid additive |
| How it cures | Hydration: reacts with water, doesn't need to dry out | Hydration, plus the polymers have to dry |
| Bond and flexibility | Lower bond strength, little flexibility | Stronger bond, some flexibility |
| ANSI rating | A118.1 | A118.4, or A118.15 for improved |
| Typical use | Where a membrane or tile maker specifies it | Most porcelain tile on concrete, cement board and walls |
Reading the bag: ANSI and ISO ratings
| Rating | What it means |
|---|---|
| ANSI A118.1 | Unmodified (dry-set) mortar |
| ANSI A118.4 | Modified mortar |
| ANSI A118.11 | Suitable for bonding to plywood (exterior-glue plywood) |
| ANSI A118.15 | "Improved" modified mortar, with higher performance |
| LHT (large and heavy tile) | Holds up thick beds under large or heavy tile without slumping |
| ISO C2, E, T, S1/S2 | C2 = improved cement mortar; E = extended open time; T = non-slip on walls; S1/S2 = deformable (flexible) |
Why some membranes called for unmodified thin-set
A sheet membrane such as KERDI or DITRA doesn't let water through. Neither does porcelain tile. Set one on the other and the thin-set is sandwiched between two layers that won't let moisture out. The polymers in a standard modified thinset mortar need that moisture to leave before they fully cure, so in that sandwich they can stay soft for a long time.
Unmodified thin-set cures by hydration, so it doesn't need to dry. That is why some membrane makers specified it for the tile on top of their membranes, and why some later developed modified mortars made to cure in that situation (Schluter's ALL-SET, for example).
Instructions change as products change. Don't go by an old job or a forum post. Use a mortar the membrane maker's current handbook lists for that membrane, tile and location. The mortar under the membrane and the mortar on top can be different. See what Schluter-DITRA is.
Which type of thinset for which tile
Porcelain and other impervious tile absorbs almost no water, so it needs a polymer-modified thin-set or the mortar the membrane maker specifies. Large and heavy tile needs an LHT mortar that holds the tile without slumping and gives full coverage.
| Situation | Usually |
|---|---|
| Porcelain floor on concrete or cement board | Modified (A118.4 / A118.15); LHT for large tile |
| Shower walls | A non-sag modified mortar; LHT for large-format wall tile |
| Over Schluter KERDI or DITRA | The mortars Schluter lists for its warranty (its own SET, ALL-SET or FAST-SET, or the unmodified type it specifies) |
| Over liquid membranes | The mortars that membrane's maker approves |
| Over a floor heating system | The mortar the heating system's maker lists for its product |
| Bonding a membrane to plywood | A mortar rated A118.11, or as the membrane maker specifies |
| Glass, translucent tile and light natural stone | White mortar (formulated for glass when setting glass), so the mortar colour doesn't show through |
| Outdoors (freeze–thaw) | High-performance flexible mortar (C2, S1 or S2) rated for exterior use |
| Fast turnaround | Rapid-setting mortar (shorter working time) |
Walls vs floors
Wall tile needs a mortar that grabs the tile and doesn't sag, so it stays where it is set while the mortar cures. Lightweight, non-sag mortars are made for this, especially for larger wall tiles. Floor tile needs full coverage under every tile, so floor mortars are made to flow and collapse their ridges when the tile is pressed in.
Two-part systems: powder plus liquid latex
Some thin-sets come as a dry powder and a liquid latex additive. The powder is mixed with the liquid instead of water, and the result is a modified mortar. Some specifications call for them.
- Only pair what the maker pairs. Most one-part modified mortars are made to be mixed with water only. Don't pour a liquid additive into one unless both makers allow it. Adding more polymer can change how it cures and can void the warranty.
- Keep the liquid from freezing. Frozen latex additive can be ruined, so it doesn't belong in a cold truck or garage over winter.
Shelf life and storage
The cement in the bag slowly reacts with moisture in the air, even before the bag is opened.
- Check the date or lot code on the bag, and the shelf life on the maker's data sheet.
- Store bags dry, off bare concrete, ideally on a pallet in a heated space.
- Close opened bags tightly and use them soon.
- Powder with hard lumps that don't crush between your fingers won't reach its rated strength. Don't use it.
Mixing thinset properly
Each thinset mix is mixed with water (or the liquid additive for two-part systems) at the ratio on the bag, using a slow drill and paddle.
- Measure the liquid exactly. Too much water weakens the mortar and causes shrinkage and hollow spots.
- Let it rest (slake) for the time listed, then remix.
- Don't add more water once it starts to stiffen. Mix a fresh batch instead.
- Spread only what you can tile within its open time. A skin on the surface means it won't bond.
Tools, clean-up and leftover mortar
Thin-set work needs only a few tools: a bucket, a slow drill with a mixing paddle, the notched trowel, a margin trowel for scraping and small batches, and a sponge with a pail of clean water.
- Clean as you go. Wipe mortar off the tile face and rake it out of the joints while it's still soft. Once it hardens it has to be chipped or ground off, and mortar left in the joints leaves less room for grout.
- Wash tools before the mortar sets. Rinse the paddle, trowels and bucket in a separate pail of water, not under a tap.
- Keep it out of drains. Cement settles and hardens in pipes. Let the rinse water settle, then let the sludge at the bottom harden and throw it out with the job waste.
Leftover mortar can't be saved for the next day. Once it has stiffened, water won't bring it back. Keep the last batch of the day small, let any leftover harden in the bucket, then knock it out and throw it away with the job waste, never down a sink.
Getting full coverage
Industry guidelines call for at least 80% mortar contact on dry interior floors and 95% in showers, wet areas and outdoors. The trowel notch decides how much mortar ends up under the tile, and larger tiles need bigger notches to get there. See what size trowel for tile for a chart.
Trowel wear
The notches wear down as the trowel scrapes across board and concrete. A worn trowel leaves lower, rounded ridges, so less mortar ends up under the tile even though the size stamped on the handle hasn't changed. Compare the teeth with a new trowel now and then, and replace it when they are worn or bent. On a large floor, start with a fresh trowel.
Back-buttering, step by step
Back-buttering is a thin coat of mortar on the back of the tile, so it sits in a full bed instead of on the tips of the ridges.
- Comb the mortar on the floor or wall with all the ridges running in one straight direction.
- Skim a thin, flat coat on the back of the tile with the flat side of the trowel.
- Set the tile and slide it slightly across the ridges, so they collapse and air escapes.
Use it on large-format tile, natural stone, tiles with a deep pattern on the back, and in showers and outdoors.
Checking coverage: lift a tile
Set a tile the normal way, then lift it straight up and look at the back. Mortar should cover it evenly, with the ridges collapsed and the corners and edges supported. Bare spots, uncollapsed ridges or a dry, skinned surface mean you need a bigger notch, back-buttering, fresher mortar or smaller areas spread at a time. Check the first few tiles, then every so often.
Mosaics and sheet-mounted tile
Small mosaics come mounted on sheets, held together by a mesh or paper backing, or by a paper or film face. Each sheet goes down as one unit, but every small piece still needs its own full bed of mortar.
- Use a smaller notch. Too much mortar squeezes up between the small pieces and fills the grout joints.
- Press each sheet in evenly with a flat float or block, so every piece is bedded and the faces sit flat.
- Keep the joints clear. Rake out mortar that comes up between the pieces before it sets, so the grout has room.
- Face-mounted sheets: the paper or film on the front comes off once the mortar has grabbed, as the maker's instructions say. Then nudge any pieces that shifted back into line.
- Glass mosaics go in white mortar made for glass, as in the table above.
Curing: when to grout and walk on new tile
Standard thin-set usually needs about 24 hours before grouting, longer in cold or damp conditions. Light foot traffic usually waits about 24 hours too, depending on the mortar and conditions. Heavy use waits longer: modified mortars need to dry to fully cure, which takes longer under large or impervious tile. See how long before you can use new tile.
Keep the area within the maker's temperature range and protect new tile from traffic and water, so the mortar can cure properly.
Rapid-setting thin-set
Rapid-setting mortars cure in hours instead of a day, so grout can go in sooner and floors can go back into use faster. The trade-off is a short working time, so they are mixed in small batches. They are handy for repairs and for jobs where downtime matters.
Heat, cold and humidity
- Hot, dry or drafty rooms shorten open time. Mortar skins over sooner and stiffens faster in the bucket. Spread smaller areas and mix smaller batches.
- Cold rooms and slabs slow curing, so grouting and foot traffic wait longer. Fresh mortar must never freeze.
- High humidity slows drying, which matters most for modified mortars under large or impervious tile.
Each maker lists the temperature range for installing and curing its mortar. In an Ottawa winter, that can mean heating the space before, during and after the job.
Thin-set vs a mortar bed
Thin-set is a thin bonding layer, a few millimetres thick, over a surface that is already flat. A mortar bed (also called mud or dry-pack) is a thick layer of sand and cement, packed and screeded to shape. Mortar beds are used to slope shower floors to the drain and to build up floors that need it; the tile is then set on the bed with thin-set.
Thin-set vs mastic
Mastic is a ready-mixed organic adhesive sold in a pail. It sets by drying, not by curing like cement.
- Where it can work: small, light wall tile in dry areas, such as many kitchen backsplashes.
- Where it doesn't belong: floors in general use, large or heavy tile, and outdoors. It dries slowly under large or dense tile.
- Showers and other wet areas: some mastics are rated for shower walls, but water can soften an organic adhesive over time. We set shower tile in thin-set, using the mortar the membrane or board maker lists.
When in doubt, use thin-set. The pail and the tile box both say where the product can be used.
Exterior tile and freeze–thaw
Outdoors, water that gets under tile, freezes and expands can push the tile off its bed. Exterior tile needs:
- A thin-set the maker rates for exterior and freeze–thaw use.
- Full coverage with no voids, so back-butter every tile.
- Frost-resistant tile, which usually means porcelain.
- A sound, sloped base that drains, with movement joints where the system calls for them.
- Installing and curing within the maker's temperature range.
Signs of a failed bond
- A hollow, drummy sound when you tap the tile with something hard.
- Cracked or crumbling grout around one tile or a group of tiles.
- Tiles that rock or click underfoot.
- Cracked tiles, or tiles that lift and "tent" up in a peak.
The usual causes are mortar that skinned over, poor coverage, too much water in the mix, a dusty or sealed surface, the wrong mortar for the tile or membrane, a floor that flexes, missing movement joints, or grouting too soon. Loose tiles can often be reset (see fixing chipped and cracked tile, or our tile repair service).
Frequently asked questions
Can I use modified thin-set for everything?
Most tile jobs use it, but not all. Some membranes and specific products call for unmodified or for the maker's own mortar. Follow the membrane and tile maker's instructions.
White or grey thin-set?
Grey for most tile. White for light natural stone, glass and light-coloured grout joints where grey could show through.
Can thin-set be used to level a floor?
No. Thin-set is a bonding layer, not a levelling product. Dips and humps are patched or levelled first (see self-levelling compound), then the tile is set.


